A dark gray sedan sits inside an open garage attached to a modern white stucco house, with a stone-paved driveway and a tall green hedge in the foreground.

Is a $0 Deductible Good for Car Insurance

Compare my rates

Free to compare

Close-up of a dark-painted car's front wheel with a gray multi-spoke alloy rim and low-profile tire, parked on asphalt.

A car seat, a fender bender, and a choice about cash on hand

A couple expecting their second child in a few months traded in their sedan for a used SUV with more room for two car seats. Money was tighter than usual since one parent was about to go down to partial pay during leave, so when they set up the new policy they looked hard at the deductible options. The higher deductible saved them a noticeable amount every month, but it also meant finding real cash fast if anything happened to the car right when they'd have the least room in their budget to absorb it.

They ended up choosing a low deductible instead of zero, splitting the difference. A few months later a shopping cart dented the door in a parking lot and they paid their deductible without touching savings meant for diapers and formula. They decided that was the right trade for where they were, and they planned to revisit it once the second income came back.

Two large broadleaf trees stand at opposite edges of a flat grassy field under an orange and blue sky at sunset, with a low distant horizon between them.

If you do

Your monthly premium goes up, sometimes substantially, and stays up for as long as you keep that deductible. In exchange, any claim you file costs you nothing out of pocket for repairs, which matters if you have no cushion for a surprise expense right now, especially during unpaid or partial-pay leave.

If you don't

You pay less every month, which adds up over a year of formula, diapers, and daycare costs. If you do have an accident, you'll owe your deductible amount before the insurer pays for repairs, so you need that amount sitting in savings or easily accessible.

Once you know the deductible that fits your budget, compare quotes at that level to see what it really costs.

Aerial night photograph of a suburban boulevard lined with trees and orange street lights, surrounded by residential neighborhoods stretching to the horizon.
Front right portion of a beige sedan, showing the headlight, grille, fog light, and side mirror, against a plain white background.

The right deductible isn't the safest one, it's the one matching the cash you have on hand now.

More articles