
What Happens if You Raise Your Car Insurance Deductible
Raising your deductible lowers your monthly premium, but it means you'll pay more yourself the next time you file a claim.
Free to compare

Here's what shifts when you raise your deductible
- Your premium drops A higher deductible means the insurer pays less per claim, so they charge you less to carry the policy. The drop is usually bigger on comprehensive and collision than on liability.
- Your out-of-pocket risk rises If you're in an accident, you'll owe your full deductible before coverage kicks in. Make sure you actually have that amount sitting in savings, not just on paper.
- Small claims may not be worth it With a higher deductible, minor damage might cost less to fix yourself than to file a claim. Think about whether you'd actually use the coverage at that level before you raise it.
- Your claim history still matters Filing more small claims because your deductible feels low can raise your rates later even with a high deductible. Raising it can nudge you toward saving claims for real emergencies.
- New parents should check savings With a baby on the way or home, unexpected expenses hit harder and faster. Don't raise your deductible unless you've set aside money you won't touch for anything else.

A new parent decides on a deductible before the baby arrives
A couple expecting their second child looked at their budget before parental leave started. One income would shrink for a few months, so they wanted to cut costs wherever they could. Their car insurance premium was one of the few recurring bills they could actually change, so they called their insurer to ask what raising the deductible on their family car would do to the monthly payment.
The drop was noticeable, enough to help with the tighter budget during leave. But before agreeing to it, they moved money into a separate savings account specifically earmarked for a possible claim, equal to the new deductible amount. They didn't touch that account for anything else, including the baby's new car seat. A few months later, a minor fender bender happened while driving with the baby in the car. Because they had the deductible already set aside, they paid it without disrupting their household budget, and the lower premium had already been saving them money every month leading up to that point.
How do I know if a higher deductible is actually worth it for my family?
It's worth it if the premium savings over time outweigh what you'd pay out of pocket in a claim, and if you can comfortably set aside that deductible amount without touching it for anything else. For a growing family, the real test isn't the math alone, it's whether you'd have that money ready during a stressful month, not just an average one.
If a claim would force you to dip into money meant for diapers, childcare or medical bills, the deductible is probably too high for where you are right now. If you already have a cushion set aside and untouched, a higher deductible is likely a safe way to lower your monthly cost while you adjust to new expenses.
Once you know what deductible fits your budget and your savings, compare quotes to see how much it actually saves you.

Can I change my deductible back later if money gets tight?
Yes, you can usually lower your deductible back down whenever you want, though it may raise your premium again. Check with your insurer about how quickly the change takes effect and whether it applies only going forward or to claims already in progress. Some insurers allow changes anytime, others only at renewal.
Does the deductible apply separately to each type of coverage?
Yes, collision and comprehensive coverage usually have separate deductibles, and you can often set them at different amounts. Check your policy to see which deductible applies to which type of damage, since a windshield claim and a collision claim may not use the same number. This affects how much you'd owe depending on what actually happens.
Will a higher deductible affect coverage for my child's car seat?
Your deductible applies before any payout, including reimbursement for a car seat damaged in an accident. Check whether your policy automatically replaces car seats after a crash regardless of fault, since many insurers do this separately from your collision deductible. This detail varies by insurer, so ask directly.

The deductible you pick isn't about the premium, it's about what you can afford the day something happens.


