A white ranch-style house with a metal roof and an open carport sheltering a dark SUV, fronted by a gravel driveway and colorful flower beds.

Do I Call the Other Persons Insurance if They Hit Me

Yes, you can call the other driver's insurer directly, but you don't have to do it alone or right away.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

A black flip-style car remote key with three buttons and a plain metal key on a split ring, resting on a white spiral-bound notebook page with a faint grid pattern.

What to do before and during that call

  • Report your own insurer first Your insurer works for you and can guide what to say to the other side. Call them before or right after, even if the accident wasn't your fault.
  • Give facts, not fault Stick to what happened in plain terms and skip opinions about blame. Anything you say can be used to shape how much they offer later.
  • Don't accept a quick settlement Early offers often come before you know the full cost, especially with a baby who rode in that car. Wait until you understand what repairs and medical checks will actually run.
  • Ask about your own coverage too Your policy may pay out faster than waiting on the other insurer to decide fault. Check what your own medical and property coverage can do while the claim is open.
  • Get everything in writing A verbal claim number isn't enough if things slow down later. Ask for written confirmation of the claim and the adjuster's contact information.
A dark-framed double-hung window with water droplets on the glass, set in light beige horizontal siding, with a blurred evergreen tree reflected or seen through the panes.

A rear-end hit on the way home from daycare pickup

You're stopped at a light with the car seat freshly installed in back, and the car behind you doesn't stop in time. No one is hurt badly, but the bumper is crushed and the car seat took a real jolt. You call your own insurer from the scene, because you know you'll need guidance before anyone else calls you first.

The other driver's insurer calls within a day asking for a recorded statement. You decline to give one on the spot and instead ask them to put their questions in writing, then you check with your own insurer about what to share. You also learn that a car seat involved in any real impact should be replaced regardless of how how it looks, so you ask both insurers whether that's covered. Within a couple weeks, the other insurer accepts fault based on the police report and pays for repairs and the seat, and you never had to navigate the back and forth without your own insurer helping you read the offers.

A white outdoor HVAC condenser unit on a concrete pad beside a building on a city sidewalk at night, with a lit street and tall buildings receding in the background.

Calling the other driver's insurer yourself

If you do

They open a claim file right away and may ask for a recorded statement. Keep answers factual and brief. You can still involve your own insurer at any point, and you don't owe the other side more than what happened and basic contact details.

If you don't

Your own insurer can often make that first contact for you, as part of handling your claim. This keeps you from accidentally saying something that lowers your payout, and still gets the claim moving.

Now you know how to handle that call, so compare quotes to find coverage that won't leave you waiting on someone else.

Why the other insurer isn't on your side

An insurance company's job is to pay out as little as it reasonably can while still meeting its legal obligations. That's true of your own insurer too, but your own insurer also has an ongoing relationship with you and a reason to keep you satisfied. The other driver's insurer has no such relationship. Their adjuster's incentive is to settle your claim for less, faster, especially before you know the full extent of repairs or any injury.

This is why recorded statements matter so much. An adjuster may ask open-ended questions designed to get you to speculate about fault or minimize how you're feeling physically. Answers given in the hours after a crash, especially with the adrenaline of a near-miss involving your child, are not always accurate. States differ on how these statements can be used later, so if you're ever unsure whether to answer a question, you can simply say you'll follow up in writing.

Your own insurer, by contrast, is bound by the contract you already have. They are required to act on your claim and often can deal directly with the other side through a process called subrogation, where your insurer pays your claim and then seeks reimbursement from the at-fault driver's insurer. This shields you from a lot of the back and forth.

The exception is when fault is completely clear and undisputed, like a stopped car being hit from behind. In those cases a short factual exchange with the other insurer is lower risk. But even then, loop in your own insurer first, because state rules about how claims and liability work can shift what's smart to say.

Front portion of a dark blue SUV shown in profile against a plain white background, with the rear of the vehicle cropped out of frame.

The other insurer isn't neutral. Treat every word to them as something that can cost you money.

Should I give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance?

Not without talking to your own insurer first. Recorded statements can be used to shift blame or minimize your claim, and you're not usually required to give one immediately. Ask to respond in writing instead, or have your insurer handle the exchange. If fault is completely undisputed, a brief factual statement carries less risk, but check your state's rules since they vary on how recorded statements can be used in a dispute.

Will my insurance rates go up if the other driver was at fault?

Usually not, since premium increases are typically tied to at-fault accidents on your own record. If the other insurer accepts fault, the claim should be recorded as not-at-fault on your end. But rules and practices vary by state and insurer, so ask your agent how a claim like this gets coded and whether a rate review happens automatically after any claim, regardless of fault.

Do I need to replace a car seat after even a minor crash?

Yes, most manufacturers recommend replacing any car seat that was in a vehicle during a collision, even a minor one, because impact can cause damage that isn't visible. Check whether the other driver's insurer or your own covers this cost as part of the claim, since policies and state requirements differ. Keep your receipt and any documentation of the crash to support that part of the claim.

More articles