A dark gray sedan sits inside an open garage attached to a modern white stucco house, with a stone-paved driveway and a tall green hedge in the foreground.

Someone Hit My Car Whose Insurance Do I Call

Call the other driver's insurance company to start a claim against them, and call your own insurer too if your policy requires it.

Compare my rates

Free to compare

A black desktop calculator, a silver ballpoint pen, and a rolled bundle of banknotes on a wooden table.

What to do about each coverage question

  • Other driver's insurer This is who pays if they're found at fault. Get their insurance company name and policy number at the scene, then call to open a claim.
  • Your own insurer Many policies require you to report any accident, even ones that weren't your fault. Call them to stay compliant, even if you expect the other side to pay.
  • Police report This document backs up your version of events. File one at the scene or soon after, since both insurers will ask for it.
  • Uninsured driver risk If the other driver has no insurance or too little, your own policy may need to cover the gap. Check what coverage you carry for this before you need it.
  • Delays and disputes The other insurer may be slow or dispute fault. If that happens, your own insurer can sometimes step in and pursue reimbursement from the other side later.

What if the other driver's insurance denies my claim?

You still have options, and a denial isn't the end of it. First find out why they denied it. Sometimes it's a fault dispute, sometimes it's missing documentation, and sometimes their policyholder never reported the accident on their end.

If you carry the right coverage on your own policy, you can file with your own insurer instead and let them pursue the other side directly. This is often faster than fighting a denial yourself, since insurers have processes for resolving these disputes between each other.

If you don't have that coverage, you can appeal the denial with more evidence, involve your state's insurance department, or in serious cases consult a lawyer. Keep every document, photo, and repair estimate, because the strength of your paper trail usually decides how this goes.

Night view down a city street lined with lit stone buildings, with two air conditioning condenser units mounted on a wall in the left foreground and blurred lights of taller buildings in the distance.

Should you also call your own insurance company

If you do

Your claim gets backup if the other driver's insurer is slow, denies fault, or the driver turns out underinsured. Your insurer can advocate for you, cover gaps, and pursue reimbursement later. Most policies actually require this report, so skipping it could affect your own coverage down the line.

If you don't

You're relying entirely on the other driver's insurance to act in good faith and move quickly. If they delay, dispute fault, or the driver wasn't insured, you may have no one covering your repairs or injuries while it gets sorted out.

Knowing who covers what helps you compare quotes with real protection in mind, not just price.

Why both insurers can end up involved

Insurance works on fault, and until fault is settled, it's not always clear which company is actually responsible for paying. Calling the other driver's insurer starts the clock on their side, but your own insurer often needs to know too, because your contract with them usually requires prompt notice of any accident, regardless of fault.

The reason your own insurer matters even when you didn't cause the crash comes down to risk. The other driver might not have insurance, might not have enough, or their insurer might contest the claim. Your policy can be the backstop in those situations, but only if you've reported the accident and only if you carry the coverage that applies. This is why the call to your own company isn't just a formality, it protects you if the simple version of the story falls apart.

What varies is how aggressively your insurer gets involved and what coverage kicks in automatically. Some policies have coverage built in for exactly this gap, others require you to have added it. Check your policy or ask your agent what's included before you assume you're covered if the other side doesn't pay.

Fault also isn't always obvious at the scene. Both insurers may investigate independently, and they can reach different conclusions before settling between themselves. That's normal, and it's part of why documentation from the start, photos, witness information, and a police report, matters more than it seems like it should in the moment.

A lit gas station canopy with blue fascia and red trim at night, with fuel pumps and a dark sedan parked beneath it.

Do I have to file a claim with my own insurance if it wasn't my fault?

Not always, but many policies require you to report any accident regardless of fault, even if you don't file a formal claim against your own coverage. Reporting protects you if the other driver's insurer delays or disputes the claim later. Check your policy's reporting requirements, since failing to notify your insurer in time can sometimes affect your coverage even when you weren't at fault.

Will my insurance rates go up if someone else hit me?

Usually not, if the accident is clearly the other driver's fault and documented that way. Insurers generally reserve rate increases for accidents where you're found at fault. Check with your insurer directly, since this can vary, and confirm the accident is recorded as not-at-fault once it's resolved.

What if the other driver gives me fake insurance information?

Verify it at the scene if possible, and call the police to file a report regardless. If the information turns out to be false, your own insurer and the coverage you carry for uninsured drivers becomes your main path to getting paid. This is part of why reporting to your own insurer matters even when someone else is at fault.

More articles